USE AND MISUSE OF THE BLEEDING TIME
Franklin A. Bontempo, M.D., Medical
Director, Coagulation Laboratory
INTRODUCTION
Appropriate use of the bleeding time remains controversial. Current
practice varies from physicians who routinely use bleeding times for pre-operative
screening to some others who refuse to perform bleeding times on anyone for any reason.
Many of the studies using bleeding times were completed before the current template device
was available and good studies that clearly define indications for its use or support it
as a predictor of bleeding at surgery are lacking.
Most hematologists usually use the bleeding time based on a combination
of clinical impressions from personal experience and a few published studies.
Description
Currently, the bleeding time using the template device is the most
reliable, reproducible, and recommended method. For adults, the spring-loaded template
lancet makes a 5 mm long, 1 mm deep cut on the volar surface of the forearm. This is
dabbed with filter paper every 30 seconds until bleeding stops. The test provides a
bleeding time value that is immediately available. The direction of the cut may be made
either parallel or perpendicular to the long axis of the arm; as long as the procedure has
been standardized in either direction, reliable results may be obtained. We prefer to make
the cut parallel to the long axis of the arm because of a perceived reduction in the
likelihood of cutting into a larger vein and because scar formation may be lessened.
Bleeding times have been performed on the finger tip and the ear lobe in the past but the
ability to standardize the technique and obtain reproducible results are questionable.
Bleeding times performed in any other site are of no known value.
Pediatric lancets are also available which make smaller cuts in
children. This is aesthetically pleasing but adult bleeding time devices may also be
accurate in pediatric patients. Again, adequate standardization of the test done by a
trained technician, who performs bleeding times frequently and is cable of obtaining
reproducible results, is of primary importance. In addition, we discourage the use of
bleeding times in infants who may be unable to remain still during the procedure and
thereby spuriously alter the result.
Long bleeding times are stopped in some laboratories above a specified
length usually, 15 minutes. While some variation in repeat testing is expected, a markedly
prolonged bleeding time is unlikely to revert to normal unless specific measures have been
taken to correct it.
Rationale
Bleeding times largely reflect platelet function and disorders causing
poor platelet function most often give abnormal results. A classic demonstration of this
is that bleeding times in hemophiliacs are generally normal while those in von
Willebrand's patients are usually prolonged (>60% of cases). This is despite the
fact that hemophilia is a much more severe bleeding disorder but has no associated
platelet defect. In contrast in von Willebrand's disease a platelet defect is usually
present.
Indications
Bleeding times are indicated when a disorder of platelet function is
suspected by history. It should not be a substitute for the latter. Von Willebrand's
disease is the most common congenital clotting disorder with an incidence of up to one
percent in the U.S. population. It is frequently associated with a patient or family
history of easy bruising, nosebleeds, or post-operative bleeding especially after dental
extractions or tonsillectomy.
Common acquired disorders of platelet function include hepatic and
renal disease and the effects of drugs, particularly those containing aspirin or any
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS) except choline magnesium trisalicylate
(Trilisate). A large number of other drugs, foods, spices, and vitamins also affect
platelet function. These include alcohol, beta-lactam antibiotics, onions, and vitamins A
and E. Excellent review articles listing all reports of substances prolonging the bleeding
time are referenced below.
Bleeding times may also be useful to monitor the response after a
therapeutic maneuver such as stopping an interfering drug, performing dialysis in a
patient with renal failure, or infusing DDAVP, platelets, or cryoprecipitate in a patient
with a previously long bleeding time.
Bleeding times are not recommended as a screening test for bleeding due
to a potentially high false positive rate in the normal population. Patients with skin
disorders may be predisposed to false positive bleeding times. Performing a bleeding time
on patients who have recently taken aspirin to determine suitability for surgery is
discouraged since defects in platelet function may persist for 7-10 days even in the face
of a normal bleeding time. Therefore if optimization of hemostasis is the goal, a normal
bleeding time in this clinical setting may provide a false sense of security.
In addition, the bleeding time will usually begin to be prolonged when
the platelet count falls to 50-60,000/mm3 even if platelet function is normal. When
platelet counts are below these values, the meaning of a long bleeding time is uncertain.
This should be considered before deciding to perform the test.
Lastly, bleeding times have been shown to be long in patients with low
hematocrits particularly renal patients with hematocrits near 18%. This is due to the
contributory effect of red blood cells on platelet behavior. For this reason red cell
transfusion may also aid in shortening bleeding times especially in selected patients.
References
George JN, Shattil SJ: The Clinical Importance of Acquired Abnormalities of Platelet
Function. NEJM 324:27-29, 1991.
Lind SE: Prolonged Bleeding Time. Am J Med 77:305-312, 1984.
For questions regarding Use and Misuse of
Bleeding Times, please contact
Franklin A. Bontempo, M.D. at: (412) 209-7322 or by e-mail: fbontempo@itxm.org
Copies of the Transfusion Medicine Update can
be obtained by contacting
Deborah Small at (412)
209-7320
Copyright © 1998, Institute For Transfusion Medicine
|